Burnham

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

AndyRM

Elder Goth
And this came up afterwards, solid German antifascists, the lyrics apply to Mahmood perfectly.

View: https://youtu.be/XyzqQ7Kq1F4?is=HjSbAVujwNcXlz65


I suspect our playlists look very similar.

Euro-thrash knocks the "Big Four" out the park.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C R

PurplePenguin

Über Member
Mahmood 'tackling the perception of two-tier policing'. I still find it extraordinary that Burnham is tolerating this pandering to the messaging of the far right. Mahmood's just in the wrong party if she wants to spout this bilge.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c3vg24wpg040o

She is playing politics which is what you like about Burnham.

My suspicion is that it is much more about their policies. Burnham has come out pro-EU, so you like him whereas there is a perfectly credible argument that reopening the discussion and creating uncertainty is unhelpful and is the reason that Starmer avoided it.
 

C R

Squire
She is playing politics which is what you like about Burnham.

My suspicion is that it is much more about their policies. Burnham has come out pro-EU, so you like him whereas there is a perfectly credible argument that reopening the discussion and creating uncertainty is unhelpful and is the reason that Starmer avoided it.

But Starmer did not avoid Mahmood's politics, quite the contrary, he embraced them gleefully.
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
She is playing politics which is what you like about Burnham.

They are politicians, and they are all, from Corbyn to Lowe, 'playing with politics': it's their job.

OK, if you read between the lines, you might have worked out that I'm not a great fan of the racism of the likes of Farage and Lowe, and I think it's self-defeating politics to try to pander to their framing of issues to try to persuade their voters to vote Labour (or Tory, for that matter), as they will only vote for bona fide racists, and what Mahmood is doing (and what Starmer was doing) is aping their framing.

So, OK, they are playing at politics, but are doing it badly, if no extra voters are persuaded. On the contrary, as has been said many times, all it does is persuade the racists that their framing is correct.

Burnham's polling does suggest that he's doing a better job of it, whether you like his policies or not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: C R
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
They are politicians, and they are all, from Corbyn to Lowe, 'playing with politics': it's their job.

OK, if you read between the lines, you might have worked out that I'm not a great fan of the racism of the likes of Farage and Lowe, and I think it's self-defeating politics to try to pander to their framing of issues to try to persuade their voters to vote Labour (or Tory, for that matter), as they will only vote for bona fide racists, and what Mahmood is doing (and what Starmer was doing) is aping their framing.

So, OK, they are playing at politics, but are doing it badly, if no extra voters are persuaded. On the contrary, as has been said many times, all it does is persuade the racists that their framing is correct.

Burnham's polling does suggest that he's doing a better job of it, whether you like his policies or not.

I wrote that before I saw this (from the Graun's John Harris), but the sentiment is the same.

1795025521202.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: C R

Psamathe

Squire
They are politicians, and they are all, from Corbyn to Lowe, 'playing with politics': it's their job.

OK, if you read between the lines, you might have worked out that I'm not a great fan of the racism of the likes of Farage and Lowe, and I think it's self-defeating politics to try to pander to their framing of issues to try to persuade their voters to vote Labour (or Tory, for that matter), as they will only vote for bona fide racists, and what Mahmood is doing (and what Starmer was doing) is aping their framing.

So, OK, they are playing at politics, but are doing it badly, if no extra voters are persuaded. On the contrary, as has been said many times, all it does is persuade the racists that their framing is correct.

Burnham's polling does suggest that he's doing a better job of it, whether you like his policies or not.
Or ... those elected to public office should be governing not "playing anything".

I see "Governance" as proposing, debating, refining, scrutinising legislation in the interests of the country as their job. They are paid by us to represent us not to play their personal ideological political games. Maybe if they spent more time scrutinising legislation for eg shortcomings, loopholes, etc. then we'd get legislation without all the unintended consequences that seem so common. Maybe we wouldn't be getting significant Government investigations highlighting the negative impacts from ill-considered Labour budgets 'cos the unintended consequences might have been addressed before the consequences hit society ...
 
Top Bottom