Does anybody here take the Greens seriously?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Rusty Nails

Country Member
Absolutely nuts. Completely impractical. Open to endless abuse.

The direction of travel with the Greens must be so frustrating for those who joined to support green issues. You have to feel sorry for those members who slogged away for years to make the party electable and to bring environmentalism to the forefront of politics. They expelled long standing members for dissenting on the trans policy, and they'll start doing the same on the zionism policy. All the work that turned a fringe party into a mainstream one is going to be undone by a relatively small number of activists.

Edit: I should point out that the Scottish Greens and the Green Party UK are different parties.

I take it none of our north of the border CC members are up for a polycule?

I think it's sad that a party with a perfectly good and clear raison d'etre seems to have become the party of choice for those people who find the Labour Party too right wing for them and CBA to go through the hard work of setting up their own party (a la Your Party UK), or the futility in electoral terms of joining the Socialist Worker Party, and in the process sideline that raison d'etre.
 

Mr Celine

Über Member
I take it none of our north of the border CC members are up for a polycule?

No thanks, it's only 20 years since we abolished the last of our irregular marriages. (Though a couple can still be found to have been married by habit and repute if that situation existed prior to 2006.)
 
Yep. Can't have people calling out the Zionists. Can't have a democratic process within the party.

Can't have the terrorist funded poeple calling out terrorist right? that's what happening...
Here we go again. Unspecified 'problematic nuances'.
Here you go
https://greens4palestine.uk/
You can read the actual motion.
And you can read the document which explains everything to the apologists.
The whole side begins and starts with lies, only credit is that it is probably written by terrorist sympathizers instead of Ai
 

the snail

Active Member
I'm still wondering how this sentiment (from the Stats for Lefties profile linked above), if it's a fair representation of the current Green Party Policy (as adopted at conference), can ever be helpful for the Green Party as a party trying to make green policies part of mainstream UK politics, surely its raison d'etre. I remain bemused.

View attachment 17924

It's a perfectly reasonable policy. Eventually every decent person will see this.
 

Psamathe

Squire
I feel rather sorry for the Green Party MPs (my MP is one). They got elected on what I considered a fairly sensible manifesto, seem to work hard still pursuing that manifesto, talking sense, being consistent with the aims they campaign with. Yet the Green Party/Mr Polanski seems to have run away from them off, on a complete tangent. Fortunately they are sticking with the mandate ans spirit they were elected on.

I saw Ellie Chowns on TV the other day and she talks sense, makes a good argument in a sensible manner and was focusing on the environment - such a massive contrast from Polanski.

I wonder if they will split from the Greens at some point before the next General Election ... though if they are considering it they probably need to do so soon to get themselves established.
 

AuroraSaab

Epic Member
It's a perfectly reasonable policy. Eventually every decent person will see this.

The link explaining the policy seems to call for the dissolution of Israel and for the region to be in the sole control of Palestinians (doesn't say which ones, given they don't have democracy), who are to be trusted to ensure that everybody who lives there, including those resident in Israel now, will live in peace without discrimination. It also says that Palestinians have the right to violent 'resistance', which sounds a bit like endorsing the events of October 7th and doesn't bode well for a peaceful assimilation of the two areas.

I think it's pie in the sky and will only serve to reposition the Greens as a fringe party, an image that they once worked so hard to change.
 

Rusty Nails

Country Member
The link explaining the policy seems to call for the dissolution of Israel and for the region to be in the sole control of Palestinians (doesn't say which ones, given they don't have democracy), who are to be trusted to ensure that everybody who lives there, including those resident in Israel now, will live in peace without discrimination. It also says that Palestinians have the right to violent 'resistance', which sounds a bit like endorsing the events of October 7th and doesn't bode well for a peaceful assimilation of the two areas.

I think it's pie in the sky and will only serve to reposition the Greens as a fringe party, an image that they once worked so hard to change.

It is definitely pie in the sky. There will be no dissolution of Israel.

There should be international action against Israel over both Gaza and their gradual invasion of Lebanon, but without the support of the US this will not happen.

Extremely sad, but true.
 
NetenYahoo is now threatening collective punishment for some shootings in the West Bank.

I am not sure how far off widespread sanctions against Israel are now. (I don't count the existing selective sanctions on olives.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: C R

C R

Squire
NetenYahoo is now threatening even more collective punishment for some shootings in the West Bank.

I am not sure how far off widespread sanctions against Israel are now. (I don't count the existing selective sanctions on olives.)

FTFY

Oh, and am sure that there will be some stern words directed at Israel's conduct. Nothing much beyond that as the response to the forced closure of the Jerusalem consulate shows.
 
Top Bottom