Does anybody here take the Greens seriously?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

briantrumpet

Timewaster
Any thoughts about how the Greens dig themselves out of this hole? ,10% seems to be the norm for them now, despite climate, AI data centres and green energy being ever more urgent topics to address.

bohekje7mpij2rddofuz4rbs5cp6hqmso3rwi6b54uve72lqgq.jpg
 

briantrumpet

Timewaster
Perhaps they should return to being soft and fluffy, and stay out of all this divisive political stuff.

That's not answering the question though. I want to see a cogent agenda for countering all the climate-wrecking stuff, and so would like to see a strong Green Party doing it (in the same way I genuinely would like to see a strong Tory Party not hooked on memes on X and racism to test the Labour Party).

It was a genuine question, an opportunity for ideas to be offered, not for mockery. Or do we just accept that a party focused on saving the planet is going to attract <10% of the voters (which doesn't seem to be the case in much of Europe).
 

Pblakeney

Shaman
That's not answering the question though. I want to see a cogent agenda for countering all the climate-wrecking stuff, and so would like to see a strong Green Party doing it (in the same way I genuinely would like to see a strong Tory Party not hooked on memes on X and racism to test the Labour Party).

It was a genuine question, an opportunity for ideas to be offered, not for mockery. Or do we just accept that a party focused on saving the planet is going to attract <10% of the voters (which doesn't seem to be the case in much of Europe).

"We" want a Green Party which will do green things.
Just as long as it doesn't affect how, where, or when "we" drive.
 

Rusty Nails

Country Member
Perhaps they should return to being soft and fluffy, and stay out of all this divisive political stuff.

Although you probably say this sarcastically there is an element of truth about it. We have plenty of political parties bashing each other over left/right issues to disillusion the voters and once the Greens get involved they just become another politically partisan party rather than one with its own USP.
 

Psamathe

Squire
Any thoughts about how the Greens dig themselves out of this hole? ,10% seems to be the norm for them now, despite climate, AI data centres and green energy being ever more urgent topics to address.

View attachment 18400
I wonder if their upsurge when Polanski took over was a combination of non-Green Party issues that are no longer the case eg Labour realising that Blue Labour under Glasman & Starmer really wasn't Labour, that there was a lot of people moving between parties, all "the end of 3 Party Politics" being discussed every 10 mins on TV, etc. But now Labour reverted to being Labour and people have moved back and Polanski has convinced us he's a fool.

I suspect that under Polanski they won't dig themselves out to their brief peak.
 

briantrumpet

Timewaster
I wonder if their upsurge when Polanski took over was a combination of non-Green Party issues that are no longer the case eg Labour realising that Blue Labour under Glasman & Starmer really wasn't Labour, that there was a lot of people moving between parties, all "the end of 3 Party Politics" being discussed every 10 mins on TV, etc. But now Labour reverted to being Labour and people have moved back and Polanski has convinced us he's a fool.

I suspect that under Polanski they won't dig themselves out to their brief peak.

I think Polanski was the reason for both their brief peak and their subsequent fall back to earth. If they had someone with his media savviness but who used that to articulate a more deep-seated Green agenda, backed up by a party machine that hadn't seemingly been hijacked by 'those for whom a green agenda is not a priority' (being polite), they might find themselves less nichey.
 

C R

Squire
I think Polanski was the reason for both their brief peak and their subsequent fall back to earth. If they had someone with his media savviness but who used that to articulate a more deep-seated Green agenda, backed up by a party machine that hadn't seemingly been hijacked by 'those for whom a green agenda is not a priority' (being polite), they might find themselves less nichey.

Alternatively, being overtly pro Palestinian in the UK is problematic. The things that seem to have dented support for the greens are standard fare un the continental left. Discuss.
 

briantrumpet

Timewaster
Alternatively, being overtly pro Palestinian in the UK is problematic. The things that seem to have dented support for the greens are standard fare un the continental left. Discuss.

I suspect that how that manifested itself here, albeit gleefully amplified by the right-wing press, is somewhat different from the pro-Palestinian voices in European Green parties, with their main focus remaining on Green issues. I've no idea what the views are on Palestine of the Ecologiste 'MP' for my bit of France, but her Facebook posts are overwhelmingly about local and national politics/policies on the environment.
 
Top Bottom