EU & Brexit Bunker

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
I saw that interview on TV and I suspect he'd been drinking at the BBC bar beforehand more from his daft reasoning (making a real fool of himself) - maybe he didn't realise it wasn't a comedy show program?

It's like Ms May today

She seems to have been watching the polls and Burnham's "response" is a more gradual version of what the electorate have been feeling for some time, a sentiment building over time.

The Bexiteer's seem to be trying to stifle our recovery but declaring decision made for life. If you buy a duff unrepairable car after having been lied to by the car salesman do you shrug and give up being able to drive around or do you return the car and get one that works?

Enough were "sold a pup" based on lies and omissions and people now realise this so want to put it right. If we fail to correct our mistakes we just won't make progress.

It would be far easier for them if Europe wasn't still just 22 miles away (and America having descended into lunacy), but what they are left with is "OK, it's not worked out, but we can't possibly see if we can mitigate/reverse the worst damage, as we'll look silly", not conceding that the 'silly' bit (given the UK losing the opt-outs and rebate we had) is has already happened.

As I've said before, Burnham needs to pitch this as Brexit being a thing of the past, a mistake that has already happened; what he's doing is looking to the future, learning from the experience of the mistakes of the past.
 

AuroraSaab

Epic Member
The most recent surveys I've seen suggest 60% or less in favour of rejoining - and that's presumably based on the exact same terms we had previously. I think there's an opportunity for closer ties, but I don't think the general public are as pro fully rejoining as you would like to think.
 

secretsqirrel

spiteful class warrior
It would be far easier for them if Europe wasn't still just 22 miles away (and America having descended into lunacy), but what they are left with is "OK, it's not worked out, but we can't possibly see if we can mitigate/reverse the worst damage, as we'll look silly", not conceding that the 'silly' bit (given the UK losing the opt-outs and rebate we had) is has already happened.

As I've said before, Burnham needs to pitch this as Brexit being a thing of the past, a mistake that has already happened; what he's doing is looking to the future, learning from the experience of the mistakes of the past.

I can understand how May has been deeply traumatised by 3 years of fighting for something she never believed in.
Brexit is done. And good riddance.

The rhetoric around the people voted for it, needs to be addressed now. Yes 17.4 million people voted for it but 29.1 million didn’t, they shouldn’t be ignored any longer.
 

secretsqirrel

spiteful class warrior
The most recent surveys I've seen suggest 60% or less in favour of rejoining - and that's presumably based on the exact same terms we had previously. I think there's an opportunity for closer ties, but I don't think the general public are as pro fully rejoining as you would like to think.

Closer ties is all that is on offer until the next election.
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
The most recent surveys I've seen suggest 60% or less in favour of rejoining - and that's presumably based on the exact same terms we had previously. I think there's an opportunity for closer ties, but I don't think the general public are as pro fully rejoining as you would like to think.

Sure, I'm not as gung-ho as some of the pro-EU commentators are now, but I'm pleased that the period for pretending that the 'Brexit relationship' with the EU is immutable and mustn't be discussed because of some historical snapshot that was bedevilled with all sorts of unknowns and lies is over. And I would expect the polls to be susceptible to quite a bit of change, as I'm expecting Burnham will be looking to influence the terms of the debate, not least as the status quo is not the rosy thing people were promised, and we saw how hard it was to defend the status quo in 2016, when actually the UK finances were in better shape than now.
 

Rusty Nails

Country Member
The most recent surveys I've seen suggest 60% or less in favour of rejoining - and that's presumably based on the exact same terms we had previously. I think there's an opportunity for closer ties, but I don't think the general public are as pro fully rejoining as you would like to think.

The public weren't that pro fully leaving at the referendum (52%) but still we fully left.

And now most voters have experienced being in as well as out.

Democracy isn't always convenient.
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
This is an extremely good read, on a number of fronts, from a pollster.

https://benansell.substack.com/p/the-denial-of-politics

1795364957722.png
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
Just in case anyone's under any illusions we'll get a sensible debate in the right wing press...

FWIW, I've never understood why anyone would put mustard on a decent piece of ham.

x44wozu2zsvk5444obu65wdxrzo2ml5e2cm6mu645zkuggcoyy.jpg
 

Psamathe

Squire
The most recent surveys I've seen suggest 60% or less in favour of rejoining - and that's presumably based on the exact same terms we had previously. I think there's an opportunity for closer ties, but I don't think the general public are as pro fully rejoining as you would like to think.
On Newsnight the other day one of the regular BBC Politican Corespondents (can't remember his name but not Mason and the one that looks like and comes across like a 12 years old child), said about the high polling for rejoining under our previous terms but he also said polling shows the support goes down to 40% if it's under "revised terms". Trouble is he didn't say who did that polling and didn't say what those "revised terms" the polling asked were - which is significant and maybe inaccurate eg technically the EU could require rejoining means adopting the € but most say that wouldn't be a requirement ...

And when polling becomes so detailed as in eg "if we were to be forced to adopt Freedom of Movement, adopt the €, adopt ..." then many would just answer "err, unsure, maybe not?" so I can imagine polling might get less reliable when it gets more detailed.

But the other day the Polish Deputy PM was being interviewed and he was explicit that were the UK to want to rejoin it would not be under our previous terms (which I can't see anybody actually expecting) but did include that some aspects might be open to negotiation and not "hard requirements".
 

AuroraSaab

Epic Member
On Newsnight the other day one of the regular BBC Politican Corespondents ....said about the high polling for rejoining under our previous terms but he also said polling shows the support goes down to 40% if it's under "revised terms". Trouble is he didn't say who did that polling and didn't say what those "revised terms" the polling asked were -
Maybe he meant the September YouGov survey.

Screenshot_20261122_174343_Chrome.jpg

...or the YouGov from last week.

Screenshot_20261122_174808_Chrome.jpg


I'm not sure what Schengen fudge they mean but wider public opinion is more complicated than the 'most people want to rejoin the EU' comments I see on here.
 
Top Bottom