War with Russia

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Ian H

Pharaoh
I am not. Answer my question, stop parrying.

Oh dear. Why do you need to know my opinion? How does it change the import of the article?

The piece stands on its own feet as a matter of record, not opinion. It's from a reliable source.

The only thing I shall say is that I chose a particular extract that would grab people's attention But if you don't read the entire thing you won't know what it says.
 

Pinno718

Slight downhill specialist
Oh dear. Why do you need to know my opinion? How does it change the import of the article?

The piece stands on its own feet as a matter of record, not opinion. It's from a reliable source.

The only thing I shall say is that I chose a particular extract that would grab people's attention But if you don't read the entire thing you won't know what it says.

I am going around in circles. You posted the article because it reflected your POV? Or... it backs up your POV? What is it?
Do you think that the expansion of NATO justified Putin's aggression towards the West?
 
Last edited:

Pinno718

Slight downhill specialist
Here's an interesting article [Source: Die Welt]

Putin used coercion/bribery to induce prisoners to serve in the military. Hardened criminals who often did their stint and came back and murdered people or in one case, a veteran threw a grenade into the court yard of a block of flats.

Add: Russia is short of 200,000 thousand police. It has always been hard to sign up recruits- wages are low and the incentive is the corruption inside the Police forces because they can 'top up' their salaries through nefarious activities. So there is a mutual understanding that the government needs police and they need the corruption to entice people to join the police..

This completes this particular circle: the lack of police means that policing veterans and ex-criminal veterans is very hard. Add the almost complete lack of rehabilitation of veterans.

So Putin does not want them to return. they are literally canon fodder: under trained and a liability should they return to civilian life.
 
Last edited:

Ian H

Pharaoh
I am going around in circles. You posted the article because it reflected your POV? Or... it back up your POV? What is it?
Do you think that the expansion of NATO justified Putin's aggression towards the West?

As far as I can see it reflects what people said at the time. You can agree or disagree with their actions as you like, but the article gives a record of what was said.

Why on earth do you need to know what anyone else thinks of it? Judge it for yourself!
 

Pinno718

Slight downhill specialist
As far as I can see it reflects what people said at the time. You can agree or disagree with their actions as you like, but the article gives a record of what was said.

Why on earth do you need to know what anyone else thinks of it? Judge it for yourself!

I read the article.
As PB said, that was before Putin started to throw Russian weight around. As soon as he got into power. he launched heavy assaults on Chechnya and Georgia.
It's fully understandable why Czech Republic, Hungary, and Poland joined NATO before Putin.
Smaller countries who felt intimidated and not able to defend themselves against such a big foe. Remember, Russia divided Poland in 1920 and infiltrated their government in the 80's - Solidarnosk?

Why did Gorbachev want 'no expansion eastwards'? Russia had posed a threat to the West for over 4 decades since the end of WW2? It was an unreasonable condition.
Equally, Bush should never had made these promises.

Ultimately, Putin has used the apparent threat of NATO as a weapon and the contrived rhetoric coinciding with that, a political tool to a) bolster his power by uniting Russians against the expansive and 'manipulative', nefarious West and b) justifying his own expansionist actions. Note; he has never overtly attacked a NATO country so, NATO serves it's purpose. NATO was formed as a defence alliance, not an attack alliance.
Subsequent Russian presidents, Andropov, Yeltsin, Medvedev never sought or took the opportunity to change the relationships with particularly Europe or the West as a whole.
This is significant. The speculations why are for a thread all of it's own.

Anyway, this does not detract from why you posted the article. It's as if you are somehow justifying Putin's antipathy and reasons for active aggression towards the West.
 

Ian H

Pharaoh
Anyway, this does not detract from why you posted the article. It's as if you are somehow justifying Putin's antipathy and reasons for active aggression towards the West.

Only in your imagination. It adds context and gives an insight into the history of relations between Russia and the West. Do you want it suppressed or something? If you are unwilling to look at all the relevant information, you'd make a crap historian.
 

Ian H

Pharaoh
I added context and history in my post.
You are still avoiding the question of what you think.
Wot FA said.

What I think is that "It adds context and gives an insight into the history of relations between Russia and the West", as I've already said.
 

Pblakeney

Shaman
What I think is that "It adds context and gives an insight into the history of relations between Russia and the West", as I've already said.

If only it was relevant to the Russia of today. It covers steps on the way but stops short of the full picture.
 

Ian H

Pharaoh
If only it was relevant to the Russia of today. It covers steps on the way but stops short of the full picture.

It has some relevance in that Putin is using it as a reason for 'pushing back' (euphemism alert). There is a genuine reason for a grudge, but I don't think many folk would regard it as a reason for wanting to occupy Ukraine (there are historical reasons for that, which have been used as justification). Essentially, Putin is attempting to empire-build, cos-playing Catherine the Great, if you like. He's also stuck, because backing down would likely mean admitting defeat, which would quite likely lead to his downfall.
 

Pblakeney

Shaman
It has some relevance in that Putin is using it as a reason for 'pushing back' (euphemism alert). There is a genuine reason for a grudge, but I don't think many folk would regard it as a reason for wanting to occupy Ukraine (there are historical reasons for that, which have been used as justification). Essentially, Putin is attempting to empire-build, cos-playing Catherine the Great, if you like. He's also stuck, because backing down would likely mean admitting defeat, which would quite likely lead to his downfall.

Yeah, most just disregard it as complete codswallop.
He is now in a war that he cannot win, and cannot lose. Donnie was stupid enough to follow suit.
 

Pinno718

Slight downhill specialist
It has some relevance in that Putin is using it as a reason for 'pushing back' (euphemism alert). There is a genuine reason for a grudge, but I don't think many folk would regard it as a reason for wanting to occupy Ukraine (there are historical reasons for that, which have been used as justification). Essentially, Putin is attempting to empire-build, cos-playing Catherine the Great, if you like. He's also stuck, because backing down would likely mean admitting defeat, which would quite likely lead to his downfall.

You cannot legislate for future tyrants.
Putin's rhetoric about NATO and the West is simply about power mongering, corruption, expansionism and uniting the nation so they will support his actions. Add; he's the strongman who is more than capable of asserting and maintaining Russia's position and power on the world stage.

It's almost like Reform/Alt-right: The country is in an imminent state of collapse because of the brown people except, in Putin's case: our country is in a state of perpetual peril... because of NATO and the nefarious, decadent, manipulative West and generate the whole narrative to suit that rhetoric. Stay in power, anoint the loyalists, line your pocket, rig elections, bully neighbours, form conducive yet wholly destructive alliances...

Oh but- it's all NATO's fault. There's no f*cking grudge. That's manufactured. You don't monopolise power and institutions as well as lock up or disappear opposition domestically because of a grudge. He's a megalomaniac. Simple.
 

Pinno718

Slight downhill specialist
Massive overnight strikes (Saturday/Sunday) on Russia. I mean massive and extensive.
It will take you a while to get through this post. Better get another mug of coffee. You can scroll through and just see the headlines in bold to get a taste of it or you can delve deep and get your burning Russian stuff fix.

Just a reminder; Zelensky promised not to strike it any oil production facilities for two weeks or so. I do not now when that is supposed to end, perhaps after the US elections. I guess that's a tight rope he has to walk unfortunately so he doesn't upset the demented or the autistic.

[Storm shadow, smaller, quicker and far less expensive than Flamingo, mainly made in Britain - also known as FP5. FP-1's have taken over the long range strike capability. The pattern is emerging that Ukraine sends in many drones to hit multiple targets in a specific area like they did in St Petersburg recently, to overwhelm Russian air defences].

We'll start with the Russian military facility in Yeltsi, 300 km's from Ukraine.
This facility produces Lithium batteries, chemical components wiring, night vision for drones, aiming equipment and other materials for the military. It was struck with Storm shadow missiles multiple times and there is really nothing left of the building.

2500km's from the border, Ukraine strikes the Omski Kauchuk petro-chemical plant with FP-1 extended range drones. It's a massive plant.

The Facility:
Omsky Kauchuk (owned by the Titan Group) is one of Russia's largest manufacturers of synthetic rubber and organic synthesis products. It handles the production of industrial chemicals like phenol, acetone, and MTBE (a fuel additive used to boost gasoline octane ratings). [1, 2]
  • Military Significance: The plant's synthetic rubbers are an essential component in high-energy solid rocket propellants, linking its supply chain to Russian ballistic missile production.
In the same area, Ukraine hit an Ozon warehouse. Constructed in 2024 at a cost of 4bn roubles.
[Moscow Times] Several industrial facilities were damaged in a drone attack on the Russian city of Tolyatti on Saturday, local authorities said, while Ukraine said it had struck a major petrochemical plant there. The facility supplies roughly 25% of the synthetic rubber market for Russia.
[Also Moscow Times] Ukraine's military also reported hitting an aircraft at the Yeysk airfield in southern Russia. Local authorities confirmed an attack in the area but said it caused only minor damage to two apartment buildings. Yeah, bollox.

[Euromaidan Press]

Russian plant supplying components for Iskander missiles reportedly struck by Ukrainian Storm Shadow missiles​

OSINT projects reported that a strike hit the Proton plant in Orel, a facility whose electronic components are used in several Russian weapons systems.

The plant reportedly supplies electronic components for Iskander-M ballistic missiles, which Russia regularly uses to attack Ukrainian cities, as well as other weapons systems, including the Pantsir-S1 air defense system.

The strike could disrupt production supporting Russia’s war effort. Photos show extensive damage to the building. Information about casualties remains unclear.


Russians photograph debris from the Storm Shadow missiles with European components and blame Europe for the wave of attacks. 'It's all the fault of Europe, they are bombing us'.

[Militarnyi]

Russia’s Energia Plant Struck by Storm Shadow Missiles, Fire Breaks Out​

The Energia plant, which manufactures power sources for cruise and ballistic missiles, including those used in Russia’s Iskander missile systems, has been struck by Storm Shadow cruise missiles.

Shortly before the strike, it was reported that the United Kingdom would provide Ukraine with an additional batch of Storm Shadow cruise missiles. They are intended to help Ukraine’s Defence Forces disrupt Russian military operations targeting Ukrainian civilian and energy infrastructure ahead of winter.

Russian finance ministry data center struck by Ukrainian forces​

Another data center damaged in conflict and in the same area, a chemical plant was struck

[UkrMedai news]
The "Marshal" factory in Luhansk—a large machine-building plant producing industrial shut-off valves for the oil, gas, chemical, and energy sectors—came under a night-time drone attack on October 23, 2026.

[KP]

Massive Blackout Hits Russian-Occupied Crimea After Drone Attacks​

In brief: A massive blackout struck Russian-occupied Crimea overnight following reported drone attacks on energy infrastructure. Monitoring channels reported disabled substations and widespread outages, while Russian-installed officials confirmed disruptions in Sevastopol.
My addition: Most, if not all of Crimea has no electricity and fuel shortages are critical to the point the military have priority and those leaving cam only leave by 1 bridge.

[KP]

All 4 Moscow Airports Halt Flights as Sheremetyevo Issues Air Raid Alert​

In brief: Russia suspended arrivals and departures at Moscow’s four airports on Oct. 23. Sheremetyevo issued an air raid alert, while Vnukovo warned passengers of prolonged waits, including aboard aircraft.

On the frontline. Russia suffers 2000 losses injured or killed in one day (Saturday). Not the highest number but the graph is just creeping upwards. 1.5m casualties to occupy 7% of Ukraine.
Holy sh*t.
 

Rusty Nails

Country Member
You cannot legislate for future tyrants.
Putin's rhetoric about NATO and the West is simply about power mongering, corruption, expansionism and uniting the nation so they will support his actions. Add; he's the strongman who is more than capable of asserting and maintaining Russia's position and power on the world stage.

It's almost like Reform/Alt-right: The country is in an imminent state of collapse because of the brown people except, in Putin's case: our country is in a state of perpetual peril... because of NATO and the nefarious, decadent, manipulative West and generate the whole narrative to suit that rhetoric. Stay in power, anoint the loyalists, line your pocket, rig elections, bully neighbours, form conducive yet wholly destructive alliances...

Oh but- it's all NATO's fault. There's no f*cking grudge. That's manufactured. You don't monopolise power and institutions as well as lock up or disappear opposition domestically because of a grudge. He's a megalomaniac. Simple.

One thing I find intriguing about opinions of NATO as a force for good or bad is the example of Horseshoe Theory where the strongest opinions against it in the UK seem to come from those strange bedfellows the far left and Reform.
 
Top Bottom