EU & Brexit Bunker

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
It is not the right time to start another divisive campaign over Brexit reversal. There’s enough problems to resolve without getting diverted.

I think that's where Burnham has pitched it right... "Let's have an honest discussion..." which gives some space for 'technical improvements' in the relationship without committing to a referendum yet. Obviously VL would be happy never ever to discuss it honestly again to cling onto the status quo, as they got the hardest Brexit they could have dreamed of. Yet still the EU is on our doorstep, those cunning foreigners.
 

Psamathe

Squire
Yet still the EU is on our doorstep, those cunning foreigners.
As well as others we considered allies proving they are anything but allies as well as other countries we at least used to be able to deal with now acting such we cannot have dealings with them (eg Russia).
 

Rusty Nails

Country Member
I think that's where Burnham has pitched it right... "Let's have an honest discussion..." which gives some space for 'technical improvements' in the relationship without committing to a referendum yet. Obviously VL would be happy never ever to discuss it honestly again to cling onto the status quo, as they got the hardest Brexit they could have dreamed of. Yet still the EU is on our doorstep, those cunning foreigners.

I would prefer it if that “honest discussion” made it clear that it does not include rejoining for a period that does not trivialise the importance of a national referendum. He has to be brave enough to strongly refute Tory/Reform claims that seeking closer cooperation is just a step towards rejoining, and not act like Starmer trying to run with the hare and the hounds.
 

Psamathe

Squire
I would prefer it if that “honest discussion” made it clear that it does not include rejoining for a period that does not trivialise the importance of a national referendum. He has to be brave enough to strongly refute Tory/Reform claims that seeking closer cooperation is just a step towards rejoining, and not act like Starmer trying to run with the hare and the hounds.
It always worries me when politicians start saying "We need a discussion ..." as too often that is just them fence sitting to see how the polling reacts to the idea plus invariably whatever the public "discuss" they just follow their ideology anyway so our "discussion" is no more than them feeling out responses from those that might fight an idea.

That said, I think Burnham is right in not declaring for any course at the moment though I'd rather he had come up with something more specific that "we need a discussion ...". eg Were he to setup a cross-party Parliamentary group (or several) to examine in more detail the impacts from various long term ways forward. Good time to do it now as membership of those committees could be proportionate on the number of MPs the parties have so Reform would be less than ½ so round down to "zero".
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
Vis-à-vis Burnham's Guildhall speech...

wcn5tchntmmnfe5ltw3ihv7cc24tqcaayqf5umqjegl35r3izq.jpg
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
An interesting thread on how Burnham might be approaching the EU question.

https://bsky.app/profile/columnist.bsky.social/post/3n2ir5d6xas2a

We’re going to leave to one side the more fundamental aspects of Indeterminacy, and observe / claim that much of British politics has been about an attempt to make things certain — this is what will happen, this is how it will happen etc etc. Burnham is rather curious because he’s a practitioner of Indeterminacy as a political tactic*. This might at first seem counter productive? How can making things less certain / more uncertain be productive?
*So was Johnson

Let’s take the EU discussion as an example. By really quite radically opening up the EU relationship as a key debate, he’s made that future relationship much less certain. Red lines or not? Rejoin or not’ Etc etc This has had the very considerable benefit of opening a whole landscape of discussion and political opportunity that barely existed before. This is a good and productive thing from all perspectives.

But it’s also had the effect of (logically) enabling everyone to participate in the discussion and fill in the gaps themselves, perhaps not necessarily in the way that Burnham et al would want. This isn’t necessarily (at all) a bad thing. There’s great advantage to be found in having one’s political opponents disclose willingly their positions and tactics far in advance of the actual conflict.

However, it does risk being on the back foot. So how has Burnham responded? By emitting another plume of uncertainty at his Mansion House speech re the timing etc of the options discussion. But if I think of one looks carefully one might imagine a process of sequential but ever more defined stages of uncertainty, leading to what I suspect maybe quite a certain outcome (in his mind at least).
 

Pross

Guru
Exactly, all we’ve had from Badenoch is “we don’t want to go through all that again”.
Farage has been bleating about mandates and stuff. We don’t generally go to the country every time we want to make a deal, or change a deal that is not good enough.

It's strange how they felt it was necessary to go against the 1975 referendum to remain in the EEC (67% in favour) but the Leave referendum (52% in favour) should be considered sacrosanct infinitum. The 'reopening divisions' comments from Badenoch were also amusing as though they have ever gone away.
 

secretsqirrel

spiteful class warrior
I don’t think Kemi thinks its fair…..

“It's quite clear that he saw this as an opportunity for him to make more concessions to the European Union but I just don't think this deal is fair.
"I don't think it's fair because it's going to increase energy bills. I don't think it's fair because it means that more young people are coming here to compete with our young people who are struggling to get jobs.
”I don't think it's fair that our farmers will now have rules made for them by people that they haven't democratically elected."
"My overall view is that this isn't fair."
 

AuroraSaab

Epic Member
It's strange how they felt it was necessary to go against the 1975 referendum to remain in the EEC (67% in favour) but the Leave referendum (52% in favour) should be considered sacrosanct infinitum. The 'reopening divisions' comments from Badenoch were also amusing as though they have ever gone away.

I didn't vote Leave but it's fair to say that the EEC was a very different thing from what morphed into the EU. I also think most people have accepted the vote and moved on. I don't hear anyone discussing it in real life. I think another vote will open up divisions again but my impression is most people aren't averse to a closer relationship with the EU via a bit of tinkering but not up for another vote on full membership.
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
I don’t think Kemi thinks its fair…..

“It's quite clear that he saw this as an opportunity for him to make more concessions to the European Union but I just don't think this deal is fair.
"I don't think it's fair because it's going to increase energy bills. I don't think it's fair because it means that more young people are coming here to compete with our young people who are struggling to get jobs.
”I don't think it's fair that our farmers will now have rules made for them by people that they haven't democratically elected."
"My overall view is that this isn't fair."

I suspect they've been workshopping the word 'fair', and decided to run with it for all it's worth. I might counter that it wasn't 'fair' that young people who were born as EU citizens had that taken away from them for such a doomed project.
 

Psamathe

Squire
Does Tim Stanley realise that he's articulating an admission that Brexit was a huge mistake?

https://bsky.app/profile/thebossross.bsky.social/post/3n2tl22xyfk24
I saw that interview on TV and I suspect he'd been drinking at the BBC bar beforehand more from his daft reasoning (making a real fool of himself) - maybe he didn't realise it wasn't a comedy show program?

It's like Ms May today
May claimed Burnham "wants to pat people on the head" by suggesting: "Remember that vote? Well, you got it wrong, didn't you. So have another go and come out with the right answer."
(from https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cvj6l8y3x1x4o)
She seems to have been watching the polls and Burnham's "response" is a more gradual version of what the electorate have been feeling for some time, a sentiment building over time.

The Bexiteer's seem to be trying to stifle our recovery but declaring decision made for life. If you buy a duff unrepairable car after having been lied to by the car salesman do you shrug and give up being able to drive around or do you return the car and get one that works?

Enough were "sold a pup" based on lies and omissions and people now realise this so want to put it right. If we fail to correct our mistakes we just won't make progress.
 
Top Bottom