We’re going to leave to one side the more fundamental aspects of Indeterminacy, and observe / claim that much of British politics has been about an attempt to make things certain — this is what will happen, this is how it will happen etc etc. Burnham is rather curious because he’s a practitioner of Indeterminacy as a political tactic*. This might at first seem counter productive? How can making things less certain / more uncertain be productive?
*So was Johnson
Let’s take the EU discussion as an example. By really quite radically opening up the EU relationship as a key debate, he’s made that future relationship much less certain. Red lines or not? Rejoin or not’ Etc etc This has had the very considerable benefit of opening a whole landscape of discussion and political opportunity that barely existed before. This is a good and productive thing from all perspectives.
But it’s also had the effect of (logically) enabling everyone to participate in the discussion and fill in the gaps themselves, perhaps not necessarily in the way that Burnham et al would want. This isn’t necessarily (at all) a bad thing. There’s great advantage to be found in having one’s political opponents disclose willingly their positions and tactics far in advance of the actual conflict.
However, it does risk being on the back foot. So how has Burnham responded? By emitting another plume of uncertainty at his Mansion House speech re the timing etc of the options discussion. But if I think of one looks carefully one might imagine a process of sequential but ever more defined stages of uncertainty, leading to what I suspect maybe quite a certain outcome (in his mind at least).