Shít graphs

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
27042.jpg
 

Pblakeney

Shaman

WTAF?!
Whoever created that needs sacking.
 

C R

Squire

Can you write down your reasoning?
 

Psamathe

Squire
Great apes on the right; a subset of great apes on the left - some double-counting there.
Plus some results from the same genus (Aphelocoma), multiple birds and no reptiles, no amphibians, etc.

And one result across a genus (eg Heliconias Butterflies), others for specific species, others down at sub-species eg Black Honey Bee.
 
Last edited:

C R

Squire
I was serious with my question, I only have a basic understanding of genetics so would like to know what's wrong with the graph. Is the star above the human column the issue here?
 
OP
OP
briantrumpet

briantrumpet

Timewaster
For those of you with a better grasp of finance than me, is Portes' criticism of the FT graph quoted in this thread fair? He thinks it's a shît graph.

https://skywriter.blue/@jdportes.bsky.social/3mzb7relcq22v

Jonathan PortesNovember 1, 2026 at 4:22 PM GMT
In addition to this absurd chart, the article is full of Daily Mail/CSJ tropes (confusing "benefits" with all state spending, talking about "work incentives" while ignoring fact PIP is non-means tested, etc, etc). Inexcusable from FT.


tejparikh.ft.com11/01/26
Britain's welfare ratchet. My column for @financialtimes.com. Political incentives, rising expectations on the state & deeper economic failings make the UK's benefits system hard to rein in. as.ft.com
cgvev7alx5xxjzgpbihtj5iq2uyou2xntyy3i64lmbkbzippiu.jpg

Since @tejparikh.ft.com has (perfectly reasonably) asked for me to be specific in my criticisms, here they are. I could go on but I think this will suffice. bsky.app


Jonathan Portes11/01/26
1. As pretty much everyone else has told you, it is just absolutely inexcusable to use a real terms chart as your *headline* to illustrate welfare spending over multiple decades (just as it would be if it were tax revenue, debt, or NHS spending). This should not need explaining to an FT journalist.
Appending @tejparikh.ft.com's (utterly unconvincing - frankly I don't think he's even convinced himself) response here, and you can also see my reply bsky.app


tejparikh.ft.com11/01/26
1.The chart serves as a high-level illustration to structure the points in my piece. 1st the largest slice of the bill, pensions, then the current focus on Pips...It is an accurate chart & feel it is fair for me to use it this way. Ofc any charts can be misused, hence I make the % of GDP point above
 

Mr Celine

Über Member
Well for a start the UK population is somewhat larger now than it was in 1950. More people, so more claimants.
 
Top Bottom