Jonathan PortesNovember 1, 2026 at 4:22 PM GMT
In addition to this absurd chart, the article is full of Daily Mail/CSJ tropes (confusing "benefits" with all state spending, talking about "work incentives" while ignoring fact PIP is non-means tested, etc, etc). Inexcusable from FT.
tejparikh.ft.com
11/01/26
Britain's welfare ratchet. My column for
@financialtimes.com. Political incentives, rising expectations on the state & deeper economic failings make the UK's benefits system hard to rein in.
as.ft.com
Since
@tejparikh.ft.com has (perfectly reasonably) asked for me to be specific in my criticisms, here they are. I could go on but I think this will suffice.
bsky.app
Jonathan Portes
11/01/26
1. As pretty much everyone else has told you, it is just absolutely inexcusable to use a real terms chart as your *headline* to illustrate welfare spending over multiple decades (just as it would be if it were tax revenue, debt, or NHS spending). This should not need explaining to an FT journalist.
Appending
@tejparikh.ft.com's (utterly unconvincing - frankly I don't think he's even convinced himself) response here, and you can also see my reply
bsky.app
tejparikh.ft.com
11/01/26
1.The chart serves as a high-level illustration to structure the points in my piece. 1st the largest slice of the bill, pensions, then the current focus on Pips...It is an accurate chart & feel it is fair for me to use it this way. Ofc any charts can be misused, hence I make the % of GDP point above