Britain has, overall, been lucky in the quality of its industrious immigrants but with 6.7m on out-of-work benefits they have perhaps been too much of a good thing. It has been madness to shovel hundreds of thousands of Brits on to sickness benefit every day while importing hundreds of thousands of migrant workers. It gives employers the easy option, and stops them trying hard to offer better pay and prospects. It stops care homes paying skilled wage for a skilled job.
The liberal case for border control is to force employers to look to the local unemployed to fill jobs. To force ministers to repair the broken work incentives. Repair the welfare state, reconnect the economy to the people currently excluded from it. It’s not a right wing or left wing: it’s about using border control to promote economic and social cohesion.
Migration is now far better controlled but still too high. Every illegal small-boat crossing is an indictment of government failure and erodes faith in the process. But overall, we see clear and significant progress. A story that Keir Starmer could have told he he been so minded. One of the drawbacks of changing Prime Minister every two years is that they never get the chance to learn. Let’s see if Andy Burnham can do any better.