Israel / Palestine

[BoldonLad]

I believe it was trivialising, and certainly did not suggest you agree with Trump

This is what I suspect Multitool meant when referring to sealioning. You continually pose questions to which you know there are no defined answers, but never putting forward your own ideas or solutions In an attempt to always seem reasonable.

The last part of your post is ridiculous as I assume, if I said "no more than a few generations" you would have questioned whether I was suggesting four.

As you wish

 

[Rusty Nails]

As you wish

QED

 

[multitool]

Will Vidkun Starmer finally say something?

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...proposals-for-us-takeover-of-gaza-david-lammy

 

[C R]

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...proposals-for-us-takeover-of-gaza-david-lammy

Lammy's statement was OK, Starmer's was a lot more equivocal.

 

[Bazzer]

If Trump is stupid enough to go ahead with this nonsense, I can see it being a fertile breeding ground for yet more violent dissent. Only this time Americans will be near, if not at the top of the list of targets.

 

[CXRAndy]

What has happened in Gaza did not start on October 7th

Certainly gave Hamas darn good thrashing though.

Don't start a war, then complain you're losing.

 

[Badger_Boom]

Lammy's statement was OK, Starmer's was a lot more equivocal.

His desire to remain friendly with Trump is compromising his ability to express an opinion. At least I hope that's what's holding him aback.

 

[All uphill]

I was not trivialising, and, I was not agreeing with Trump's suggestion. I was questioning the "send them back where they came from" bit.

My question was "how many generations before you become a "native"?", so far, no answer, unless you are suggesting more than 3 will do it?

Here's my answer.

If you are a zionist it's enough to step off the plane.
If you are Palestinian 1300 years isn't enough.

 

[BoldonLad]

Here's my answer.

If you are a zionist it's enough to step off the plane.
If you are Palestinian 1300 years isn't enough.

I get your point, but, I am neither of those categories, and, don't see either of them as helpful to the current Gaza/Israel situation, or, indeed, to the wider migration situation.

 

[C R]

His desire to remain friendly with Trump is compromising his ability to express an opinion. At least I hope that's what's holding him aback.

Yep, peace in our time.