Archie_tect
Active Member
Yes, in essence.If Scotland gets independence (and joins EU), will we have a "NI border problem" in Northumberland?
Yes, in essence.If Scotland gets independence (and joins EU), will we have a "NI border problem" in Northumberland?
No other international border has the good Friday agreement.the obvious weakness in this argument was "how does the EU deal with other (non) EU Countries, with whom it has a land border"?
As a in independence supporter and a depressed pragmatist, I'm bleakly confident that's an entirely theoretical question. The only circumstances under which Scotland will be allowed another independence referendum would be if there was a guaranteed 'no' result, or with conditions (such as a requirement for 66% or more 'yes' vote) that would make it unwinnable, even if the Scottish Government were to agree to such terms. Which they wouldn't.If Scotland gets independence (and joins EU), will we have a "NI border problem" in Northumberland?
No other international border has the good Friday agreement.
It complicates issues as it stipulates that there can be no difference on either side of the border. So Brexit and the good Friday agreement are not compatible if we left the CU:SM.
But no one told you that.
The ''No forever'' is possible but that will depend on how much the government rile the independence side and erode the unionist side. The trajectory of this government makes me think that they will continue to respectively rile and erode. And that could provoke an insurrectionary movement. Personally, though I was broadly pro-unionist until relatively recently, I wouldn't lift a finger to prevent this from happening, especially if it's clearly done against the will of a Scottish majority. While England seems bent on showing itself as good for nothing, the Union is good for nobody in Scotland.As a in independence supporter and a depressed pragmatist, I'm bleakly confident that's an entirely theoretical question. The only circumstances under which Scotland will be allowed another independence referendum would be if there was a guaranteed 'no' result, or with conditions (such as a requirement for 66% or more 'yes' vote) that would make it unwinnable, even if the Scottish Government were to agree to such terms. Which they wouldn't.
More realistically, Johnson, or whichever soulless Tory horror succeeds him, will just keep saying "no". Forever.
That’s exactly how I see it too. The Westminster government is like an abusive and jealous partner saying “You’ll never prosper outside this relationship and I’m not going to let you try.” As a resident of England I find it shameful, despite feeling regret that it has come to this.The ''No forever'' is possible but that will depend on how much the government rile the independence side and erode the unionist side. The trajectory of this government makes me think that they will continue to respectively rile and erode. And that could provoke an insurrectionary movement. Personally, though I was broadly pro-unionist until relatively recently, I wouldn't lift a finger to prevent this from happening, especially if it's clearly done against the will of a Scottish majority. While England seems bent on showing itself as good for nothing, the Union is good for nobody in Scotland.
Makes you wonder why the Irish have such a negative view about us.....
“Surely the message must go out to all countries around the world that this is a British government that doesn’t necessarily keep its word and doesn’t necessarily honour the agreements it makes” - Leo Varadkar https://t.co/JdEVWFhIUe
Perfidious Albion….Confirms what has been said about the UK in here in Asia for a long time. The words 'irresponsible' and 'untrustworthy' are used quite a lot.
For £1.99 they could buy a sticker to change GB to UK.Many users report discrimination being a major problem as a number of companies across Europe began to refuse Euro account bank details “if they contained the country code ‘GB’” according to a report in City AM.