Gender again. Sorry!

[Bromptonaut]

It doesn't matter how one tries to move it on, we just end with Aurora regurgitating the same memes, and telling everyone that they don't care for women / girls /children. So tedious.

To be scrupulously fair to @AuroraSaab and starting from a totally neutral POV those from our side just keep saying much the same too.

We're not going to agree are we??

 

[AuroraSaab]

I'm just as tired of your repetitive and pompous pronouncements, Monica, but other people keep resurrecting the thread with gender nonsense so here we are....

There's no such thing as a trans child. There are children in mental distress related to numerous things, there are children with body dysphoria. The 'trans child' is an invention of adults who need children to be transgender in order to justify their own journey.

 

[monkers]

I'm just as tired of your repetitive and pompous pronouncements, Monica, but other people keep resurrecting the thread with gender nonsense so here we are....

There's no such thing as a trans child. There are children in mental distress related to numerous things, there are children with body dysphoria. The 'trans child' is an invention of adults who need children to be transgender in order to justify their own journey.

I'm the one here who actually raised a trans child. Trying walking the walk as well as having to talk the talk. You are obtuse and not prepared to accept the lived experiences of others. Not only did I raise a trans child, but I've had many other trans people visit my house.

Little of what you claim rings true. I've seen material reality up close. If anyone is pompous it is you, pretending to know and understand everything. It's clear to me that you nothing useful at all. Trans children are just a useful little device in argument for your own ends.

Most of what you say is fear-based and wrong; most of your argument is bogus.

 

[Rusty Nails]

To be scrupulously fair to @AuroraSaab and starting from a totally neutral POV those from our side just keep saying much the same too.

We're not going to agree are we??

As long as "our side" wins, who cares.

 

[Pale Rider]

As long as "our side" wins, who cares.

Every thread on the whole of CC is a hamster wheel.

It's just that on this one we have two very determined and very fit hamsters.

 

[Bromptonaut]

Every thread on the whole of CC is a hamster wheel.

It's just that on this one we have two very determined and very fit hamsters.

More than two I think....

 

[Pale Rider]

More than two I think....

Quite possibly, but it would be a very quiet and dull forum if every post had to offer a fresh perspective.

 

[CXRAndy]

One can only hope and pray (if anyone is religious ) their path has not been irreversibly blocked behind

 

[Craig the cyclist]

There's no proof gender identity even exists, nevermind that it's innate. The whole idea of 'gender identity' rests on Man-made stereotypes of male and female behaviour, dress, roles etc. Without those stereotypes there's nothing to transition to.

If two babies, one male one female, were shipwrecked on an island and miraculously lived until adulthood, how would they know their 'innate' gender identity? Without stereotypes of male and female dress and behaviour around them to refer to what would be their frame of reference for having say a 'male' gender identity? Their sex would be male and female and they would likely know their sexuality, but how can gender identity be innate when it can't exist without reference to already the long established regressive stereotypes of what 'man' and 'woman' means?

There's no evidence, as far as I know, that elderly gay people with dementia forget they are gay. There does seem to be some evidence that elderly transgender people forget they have transitioned. Why would that happen if gender identity is innate?

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-43365446.amp

They may not, or may, know their inate sex, but on the upside for them at least they wouldn't have to put up with 478 pages (and counting) of a few entrenched middle-class pseudo-academics arguing over what the difference is between boys and girls.

 

[theclaud]

The wheel is spinning but the hamster is dead.

 

[monkers]

The wheel is spinning but the hamster is dead.

And people are busy watching it be flung around at speed while arguing over what sex to put on the death certificate.

 

[AuroraSaab]

You are obtuse and not prepared to accept the lived experiences of others.

Other people's lived experiences also matter. Not everything is about you and what you want.

 

[classic33]

Other people's lived experiences also matter. Not everything is about you and what you want.

Likewise, with yourself.

 

[Pale Rider]

The wheel is spinning but the hamster is dead.

There are two hamsters, are both dead?

Or is it only the rodent you disagree with that's carked it?

I reckon at least one must still be alive otherwise the wheel would have stopped spinning.

 

[monkers]

There are two hamsters, are both dead?

Or is it only the rodent you disagree with that's carked it?

I reckon at least one must still be alive otherwise the wheel would have stopped spinning.

Spinning - that's exactly the problem here. The false narrative of what the law says, and what the data proves.

This guy sums it up ...


View: https://youtu.be/GKLu8Oq5BXY