Oh ffs. Stop being disingenuous. The data shows that transwomen comit crimes at the same rate as other men. The fact that these men comit numerically fewer violent crimes than non trans identifying men simply because there are fewer of them is irrelevant. So do men in wheelchairs. So do Orthodox Jewish men. So do blind men. Nobody thinks men in wheelchairs should have the option of being placed in a women's prison.
If and when we reach a point where women commit violent and sexual crime at the same rate as transwomen/men then there will be a meaningful discussion to be had about whether prisons should be mixed sex or single sex. We are a long, long way from that point.
In the first post with the table, I admit I was slightly deliberately naughty.
In the second post I deliberately included the relevant paragraph that helped you notice what I had done.
I then agreed with you that the numbers were as you said they were.
Yes I led you by the nose to the facts. This needs doing because you were propagating propaganda on the transgender / trans data.
Now for the real numbers ... for the year 2021/22 ... England & Wales.
Number of arrests ....................... men ..... 560 694
women ..... 97 990
transgender people ...... unknown
trans people ....... unknown
men .... 560 694 x 0.45 = 252 312
women .... 97 990 x 0.55 = 53 895
So yes we agree incidences of male violence were about 5 times higher. Nobody will be surprised that male violence is a higher number, though many may be surprised that 55% of female arrests are for violence against the person.
Next ...
We can not say that 70% of transgender prisoners have committed sexual or violent crime, though undoubtedly many will have.
In the absence of the official data, it is not acceptable to simply conjure numbers out of thin air. The number is not 70%. The number is unknown.
There is no data that says that trans women offend at the same rates as men. The lies on this have been thoroughly debunked and you know it.
Further we can not simply say that because some people think that the rate is 70% for transgender people, therefore it is the same for trans people, it's clearly nonsense, but conspiracy theorists lap this stuff up to the detriment of those people who are innocent of any crime being committed, subsequently targeted and harmed by those stupid enough to believe what trans haters write in the media or on the internet.
