multitool
Guest
That's no way to talk about Hamza Yusuf
Last edited:
Starmer's vision quest
- Thread starter mjr
- Start date
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
That's no way to talk about Hamza Yusuf
AndyRM
Elder Goth
You've got your Muslims mixed up.
multitool
Guest
You are quite right. Hamza Yousaf.
Xipe Totec
Something nasty in the woodshed
It's 'Humza'. And you're really not doing yourself any favours.
multitool
Guest
Yeah, I typed Humza, and then didn't spot that auto-correct had changed it back.
It's the worse crime in the world to conflate two spellings of what is the same name, isn't it.
ps. Just had a quick count of muslim countries I have chosen to visit and its 16, including all but one of the countries surrounding Gaza. Clearly I know fùck all about the Islamic world.
Last edited:
Xipe Totec
Something nasty in the woodshed
Cool story bro, as da kidz absolutely never say.
And this has what, precisely, to do with implying that a Scotsman is an English Tory?
multitool
Guest
Yeah it was cool. Not all of us have an entirely parochial mindset.
What does it have to do with <blah>?
Only that you seem to have forgotten that Scotland has a devolved government.
Xipe Totec
Something nasty in the woodshed
What the howling blue fück are you on about? Are you OK?
multitool
Guest
OFFS
Can you not even keep track of the line of debate you started?
Bit early to be on the Buckfast isn't it?
Xipe Totec
Something nasty in the woodshed
What's your point? Are you trying to refer to this comment?
Which is pointing out the fact that whoever Scotland votes for, the government we end up with is chosen by English voters like you. It's kind of significant to a discussion where, despite your dissembling, you have been sneering at Scotland's elected representatives and dismissing them - and by definition, the people who elected them, as irrelevant.
If it's not that, then I have no fücking idea what the hell you're on about. Maybe you could try and be clearer.
Which is pointing out the fact that whoever Scotland votes for, the government we end up with is chosen by English voters like you. It's kind of significant to a discussion where, despite your dissembling, you have been sneering at Scotland's elected representatives and dismissing them - and by definition, the people who elected them, as irrelevant.
If it's not that, then I have no fücking idea what the hell you're on about. Maybe you could try and be clearer.
icowden
Legendary Member
That's not true though is it. The Government of the UK is elected by the people of England, Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales.
That the Nationalist parties only stand for election in their home nations is a matter for them.
It is, however, another strong argument for PR in that at the moment those Nationalist parties are very much excluded within Westminster.
cookiemonster
Veteran
- Location
- Far away from the asylum
The Tories haven't won an election in Scotland since the 1950s.
How many Tory Govs have we been subjected to due to the English Electorate since then?
Xipe Totec
Something nasty in the woodshed
It's a matter of simple arithmetic that Scotland's constiuencies have almost never made a difference to what government is elected to Westminster - I think two Labour governments in the last 60+ years owed their majority to Scottish seats. As @cookiemonster said, Scotland has not recorded a majority of Tory seats in nearly 70 years, so it's entirely fair to say Scottish votes don't count towards Westminster governments. And if the politicians Scotland does elect are denied the ability to contribute in Westminster, say, by having an un-hijacked Opposition Day vote, then it's similarly fair to wonder whether Scottish votes count at all.
Can't find any concrete info, but it's often repeated on Indy social media that the SNP would not be allowed by law to field candidates outside of Scotland - but if they were, and they achieved a majority of seats across the UK, the law would also mean they were not allowed to form a government in Westminster. If that is true I don't know why it would be the law, but realistically it might be the usual Twitter b0llocks!
C R
Über Member
I can't see how your second paragraph could be true, though it is obvious that any SNP candidate outside of Scotland would have an uphill battle in front of them, to say the least. Personally, I can say now that if the SNP fielded a candidate in my Englandshire constituency they'd definitely have my vote.
